Top Menu

Newt Gingrich: Leading GOP Presidential Candidate: “Palestinians are ‘invented’ People”

What if a Muslim leader said that the Israelis are “invented” people? It would be cause to saber rattle against the said nation or drop bombs on them.

Gingrich calls Palestinians ‘invented’ people

(AlJazeera)

Republican White House hopeful Newt Gingrich has stirred controversy by calling the Palestinians an “invented” people who could have chosen to live elsewhere.

The former House of Representatives speaker, who is the frontrunner for the Republican nomination for the 2012 presidential race, made the remarks in an interview with the US Jewish Channel broadcaster released on Friday.

Asked whether he considers himself a Zionist, he answered: “I believe that the Jewish people have the right to a state … Remember, there was no Palestine as a state. It was part of the Ottoman Empire” until the early 20th century,

“I think that we’ve had an invented Palestinian people who are in fact Arabs, and who were historically part of the Arab
community.

“And they had a chance to go many places, and for a variety of political reasons we have sustained this war against Israel now since the 1940s, and it’s tragic.”

Most historians mark the start of Palestinian Arab nationalist sentiment in 1834, when Arab residents of the Palestinian region revolted against Ottoman rule.

Israel, founded amid the 1948 Arab-Israel war, took shape along the lines of a 1947 UN plan for ethnic partition of the
then-British ruled territory of Palestine which Arabs rejected.

More than 700,000 Palestinians were forced from their lands by Zionist armed groups in 1948, in an episode Palestinians refer to as the Nakba or “catastrophe”.

‘Irrational hostility’

Gingrich’s comments drew a swift rebuke from a spokesman for the American Task Force on Palestine, Hussein Ibish, who said: “There was no Israel and no such thing as an “Israeli people” before 1948.

“So the idea that Palestinians are ‘an invented people’ while Israelis somehow are not is historically indefensible and inaccurate.

“Such statements seem to merely reflect deep historical ignorance and an irrational hostility towards Palestinian identity and nationalism.”

Sabri Saidam, adviser to the Palestinian president, told Al Jazeera, “This is a manifestation of extreme racism and this is a reflection of where America stands sad, when Palestinians don’t get their rights…this is sad and America should respond with a firm reaction to such comments that, if let go, more of which will come our way,”

“Let me ask Newt Gingrich if he would ever entertain the thought of addressing Indian Americans by saying that they never existed, that they were the invention of a separate nation, would that be tolerated?”

“Let’s also reverse the statement; let’s put ourselves in “the shoe of Jews who are listening now. Would they ever accept such statements being made about them?”

Saidam said, “I think it’s time that America rejects such statements and closes the door to such horrendous and unacceptable statements.”

Gingrich also sharply criticised US President Barack Obama’s approach to Middle East diplomacy, saying that it was “so out of touch with reality that it would be like taking your child to the zoo and explaining that a lion was a bunny rabbit.”

He said Obama’s effort to treat the Palestinians the same as the Israelis is actually “favouring the terrorists”.

“If I’m even-handed between a civilian democracy that obeys the rule of law and a group of terrorists that are firing missiles every day, that’s not even-handed, that’s favouring the terrorists,” he said.

He also said the Palestinian Authority and Hamas, which governs the Gaza Strip, share an “enormous desire to destroy Israel”.

The Palestinian Authority, which rules the occupied West Bank, formally recognises Israel’s right to exist.

President Mahmoud Abbas has long forsworn violence against Israel as a means to secure an independent state, pinning his hopes first on negotiations and more recently on a unilateral bid for statehood via the UN.

Gingrich, along with other Republican candidates, are seeking to attract Jewish in the US support by vowing to bolster Washington’s ties with Israel if elected.

He declared his world view was “pretty close” to that of Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and vowed to take “a much more tougher-minded, and much more honest approach to the Middle East” if elected.

, , , , , , , ,

  • Pingback: Dr. Oz Thinks Anti-Muslims Sugar-Daddy Sheldon Adelson is “Not So Bad” | Islamophobia Today eNewspaper

  • SKhan

    @Theiving Zionist Bully:

    Palestinian culture is different from the culture of other arabs. (Arab readers, please give him the details). Also, Palestinians speak a different dialect of Arabic. As someone pointed out above, the Muslim/Arab rulers of Palestine ruled it for a longer period than the ancient Jewish rulers. Muslims/Arabs have lived in Palestine since the 7th Century. Palestinian Arab nationalism has existed since the 1834 Arab Revolt in which Palestinian Arabs revolted against their Ottoman rulers. The term “Palestinian” has been used to describe Arabs living in Palestine before the State of Israel even.

    We are not calling for an end to Israel. We are calling for a change in American and Israeli foreign policy, and for the creation of a country for the people who lived their from before the State of Israel existed. Also, not all Jews are Israeli.

  • Thieving Zionist Bully

    1) The strip of land currently known as Israel was a part of the Ottoman Empire until the early 20th century. This is a fact. The Palestinian people were historically a part of the wider Arab community. This is also a fact. Same language, same religion. All countries in the world have different provinces in which there are variations in food, music, clothing etc… Language and religion are a very strong component of identity. We are not debating facts here, we are debating meaning, significance and implication.

    2) The Palestinian people had a chance to go many places – this sadly to say, is not a fact. The displaced Palestinian people have been refused citizenship, not only by Israel but by all of her Arab nations. This is a tragedy. Of the millions of people displaced during the horrible wars of the early 20th century, only the Palestinians remain in refugee camps. Again, no facts to debate here, only meaning, significance and implication.

    3) Throughout history there have been all sorts of bizaare statements made about the Jews. For example, that they control the global financial system, they drink childrens blood in cultic sacrificial rituals, they’re all sexual perverts and communists, and of course they fabricated the holocaust in order to justify the oppression of the Palestinian people. If you tried to tell the Jews that they are an “invented” people, it is unlikely they would be particularly offended – believe me, we’ve heard a lot worse.

    4) The Lord of Israel is certainly no bunny rabbit. Like a Lion in Zion, as they say…..

    5) Hamas DOES harbour an enormous desire to destroy Israel. Read the covenant. Hamas is not the first group in history who has harboured this enormous desire and we can all rest assured that they won’t be the last.

    3) We are indeed all invented people. The Jews invented themselves a long, long time ago, and have a very VERY strong sense of identity. We are extremely proud of our contributions to history, religion, literature, art, science, etc… Indeed, we have been repeatedly accused of harbouring a smug sense of superiority. What are the Palestinian people proud of? Other than your resistance against Israel, what is it that binds you together? It takes more than a common enemy to forge a solid and secure identity.

  • http://www.bandofstrangers.org Jack Cope

    Full of ‘Christian’ spirit today Mr Pork? Or maybe Christmas spirits if you’ll indulge me in a bad pun…

    Jack

  • Sir David ( Illuminati membership number 5:32) Warning Contains Irony

    Sorry truth seeker but the mad dont get a vote .

  • http://gmail Truth Seeker

    @ Kafir Harby:I SECOND YOU.There will never ba a state called Palestine.Those Mohammadan Arabs should be settled in Jordan or Syria.The west Bank Judea and Samaria should be settled with Christian Arabs and the Jews only.No room in the Inn for Mohammadans!!!!

  • JD

    Well this will get him the Zionistscum and CHristian Zionist Scum Israel-First traitor vote

  • jungle

    I saw this argument years ago on extremist right wing forums, which hints at where Gingrich is coming from.

    It’s a nonsensical argument anyway: even if ‘Palestinian’ were a recently invented word (which it isn’t), so what? These people – called Palestinians or not – have clearly lived in the area now referred to as Israel or Palestine for many generations. Presumably he doesn’t claim Ramallah and its population were fabricated by the Arab League as an elaborate hoax in 1948. Regardless of what national label you attach to them, they have a claim to live in that broad area.

    The argument makes no sense. It makes no sense AT ALL. It’s like saying “Cornishness” was invented in 1850, they’re actually just all Celts, and so all Cornish people should get out of England and go to a Celtic country like Wales. It’s ludicrous.

    It’s just a dog-whistle to transmit to the Islam-haters in the Republican party that he is one of their fellow haters.

  • http://www.inspiredbymohammed.com/ Inspired by Mohammad

    Gingrich and Israel: He talks a big game, but is it just empty words?
    Joshua Mitnick | The Christian Science Monitor | Dec 11, 2011

    http://www.alaskadispatch.com/article/gingrich-and-israel-he-talks-big-game-it-just-empty-words

    Republicans have promised to move the US embassy to Jerusalem from Tel Aviv, symbolically recognizing Israel’s claim of the city as its capital. But the remark made by Mr. Gingrich is likely to resonate with many Israelis who still cast doubt on the Palestinians’ national identity.

    The Palestinians have condemned Gingrich and likened his comment to former Israeli Prime Minister Golda Meir’s 1969 denial of the existence of the Palestinians as a nation.

    Gingrich doubled down on the idea in last night’s GOP debate in Iowa, saying “‘Palestinian’ did not become a common term until after 1977″ — a statement contradicted by, among other things, the formation of the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) in 1964.

    Gingrich’s staff said that he still supports a Palestinian state despite his recent remarks.

    Indeed, if the US were perceived as more hardline than the Israeli government it would hurt its already-troubled role as a trusted mediator in any future peace process.

    .By questioning the foundation of Palestinian identity, Gingrich is aligning himself with the approach of Israel’s ideological Jewish settlers to the conflict, says Mitchell Barak, a public opinion expert and a former adviser to Mr. Netanyahu.

  • http://www.inspiredbymohammed.com/ Inspired by Mohammad

    Webdawah,

    Don’t be so sure.

    Gingrich is toast now. He won’t be getting the GOP nomination and is in fact backtracking and saying he supports the two state solution.

  • http://webdawah.blogspot.com/ Webdawah

    It’s truly weird that a foreign country has a strangle hold on the politicians of another.

  • SKhan

    @Kafir Harby:

    Funny you should mention that. I went to his facebook page earlier and liked it so that I could post. I began posting about his hypocrisy (he used to support Shariah Law groups and he flip flopped about U.S. action in Libya), racism (Because he said Palestinians are an invented people, I pointed out that there has been Arab nationalism in Palestine since 1834 and that Arabs have lived in Palestine since the 7th century, and that Palestinian culture -Palestinian Arabic, clothing, food- is different from the culture of other Arabs), bigotry (He claimed that Muslims are spreading Shariah Law in America, so I pointed out that the CIA world factbook says that the U.S. Muslim population is about 2% or less) and I posted my sources as well and a few minutes later, my comments were removed. So much for freedom of speech :)

  • U.S.S Pamela Jeller

    http://www.aljazeera.com/news/americas/2011/12/2011121134849161706.html

    It is a shame when people make horrible statements, but even more monstrous when they defend those statements.

    Gingrich’s statements need to be focused on. He must not be allowed to get away with this. Period.

  • Jd

    Its funny how these zionist Christain zionist Isreal firster Mulim haters blame muslims for pushing Taqiyya Jihad muslim stealth conquest push there religion on everyone when there love of israel is based on religion

  • Jd

    If we are going to back back to history and give the land back to people who once lived there but got kicked out then that is going to be a long list and most of these country are arab now

    Kingdom of Egypt
    Hittite
    Assyrian
    Babylonian
    Persian
    Macedonian
    Rome
    Byzantine
    Sassanid
    The Caliphite
    Seljuk
    Crusaders
    Saladin Empire
    Ottoman
    EU

  • Jd

    “The extended kingdoms of David and Solomon, on which the Zionists base their territorial demands, endured for only about 73 years… Then it fell apart… [Even] if we allow independence to the entire life of the ancient Jewish kingdoms, from David’s conquest of Canaan in 1000 B.C. to the wiping out of Judah in 586 B.C., we arrive at [only] a 414 year Jewish rule.”
    – Illene Beatty, Arab and Jew in the Land of Canaan
    “Palestine became a predominately Arab and Islamic country by the end of the seventh century. Almost immediately thereafter its boundaries and its characteristics – including its name in Arabic, Filastin – became known to the entire Islamic world, as much for its fertility and beauty as for its religious significance… In 1516, Palestine became a province of the Ottoman Empire, but this made it no less fertile, no less Arab or Islamic… Sixty percent of the population was in agriculture; the balance was divided between townspeople and a relatively small nomadic group. All these people believed themselves to belong in a land called Palestine, despite their feelings that they were also members of a large Arab nation… Despite the steady arrival in Palestine of Jewish colonists after 1882, it is important to realize that not until the few weeks immediately preceding the establishment of Israel in the spring of 1948 was there ever anything other than a huge Arab majority. For example, the Jewish population in 1931 was 174,606 against a total of 1,033,314.”
    – Edward Said, The Question of Palestine

    http://www.ilaam.net/Intl/ZionistMyths.html

  • Khushboo

    GINGRICH FOR PRESIDENT !!!!!!!

    LOL that’s never gonna happen!

  • Yusuf

    Americans are an invented people, and that can’t really be argued against.

  • TheBig_T

    This is stupid
    if Plaestine is an “Invented” nation, then why did Israel need weapons to take control of the land.
    and also, If palestine was Invented, then why was there people living in that area, or do these Idiots think that the land was Barren and had nothing.

    this supports the Arabophobic sentiments that Arabs are just violent without reason.

Powered by Loon Watchers