Top Menu

Qur’an Burning: The causes of the protests in Afghanistan

Afghan Protesters

Afghans carry a protester injured during an anti-U.S. demonstration in the northern city of Kunduz. (Ezatullah Pamir, Associated Press)

More than 30 people have been killed in the violence that erupted after American personnel burned Qur’ans on a US air base in Afghanistan.

In the wake of the protests, many are asking, “Why are Afghan Muslims so angry over burning the Qur’an?

After all, it’s just a book! Why would Muslims get violent over it!?! 

Glenn Greenwald explains why misleading media coverage leaves the public with a false impression.

The causes of the protests in Afghanistan

by Glenn Greenwald, Salon

(H/T: Saladdin)

Most American media accounts and commentary about the ongoing violent anti-American protests in Afghanistan depict their principal cause as anger over the burning of Korans (it’s just a book: why would people get violent over it?) — except that Afghans themselves keep saying things like this:

Protesters in Kabul interviewed on the road and in front of Parliament said that this was not the first time that Americans had violated Afghan cultural and religious traditions and that an apology was not enough.

This is not just about dishonoring the Koran, it is about disrespecting our dead and killing our children,” said Maruf Hotak, 60, a man who joined the crowd on the outskirts of Kabul, referring to an episode in Helmand Province when American Marines urinated on the dead bodies of men they described as insurgents and to a recent erroneous airstrike on civilians in Kapisa Province that killed eight young Afghans.

“They always admit their mistakes,” he said. “They burn our Koran and then they apologize. You can’t just disrespect our holy book and kill our innocent children and make a small apology.”

And:

Members of Parliament called on Afghans to take up arms against the American military, and Western officials said they feared that conservative mullahs might incite more violence at the weekly Friday Prayer, when a large number of people worship at mosques.

Americans are invaders, and jihad against Americans is an obligation,” said Abdul Sattar Khawasi, a member of Parliament from the Ghorband district in Parwan Province, where at least four demonstrators were killed in confrontations with the police on Wednesday.

The U.S. has violently occupied their country for more than a decade. It has, as Gen. Stanley McChrystal himself explained, killed what he called an “amazing number” of innocent Afghans in checkpoint shootings. It has repeatedly — as in, over and over — killed young Afghan children in air strikes. It continues to imprison their citizens for years at Bagram and other American bases without charges of any kind and with credible reports of torture and other serious abuses. Soldiers deliberately shot Afghan civilians for fun and urinated on their corpses and displayed them as trophies.

Meanwhile, the protesters themselves continue to be shot, although most American media accounts favor sentences like these which whitewash who is doing the killing: “running clashes with the police that claimed the lives of another five Afghan protesters” and “in Nangarhar Province, two Afghans protesting the Koran burning were shot to deathoutside an American base in Khogyani District” and “protesters angry over the burning of Korans at the largest American base in Afghanistan this week took to the streets in demonstrations in a half-dozen provinces on Wednesday that left at least seven dead and many more injured.”Left at least seven dead: as As’ad AbuKhalil observed, “notice that there is no killer in the phrasing.”

It’s comforting to believe that these violent protests and the obviously intense anti-American rage driving them is primarily about anger over the inadvertent burning of some religious books: that way, we can dismiss the rage as primitive and irrational and see the American targets as victims. But the Afghans themselves are making clear that this latest episode is but the trigger for — the latest symbol of — a pile of long-standing, underlying grievances about a decade-old, extremely violent foreign military presence in their country. It’s much more difficult to dismiss those grievances as the by-product of primitive religious fanaticism, so — as usual — they just get ignored.

UPDATE: Beyond all these points, it’s perversely fascinating to watch all of this condescension — it’s just a book: who cares if it’s burned?  – pouring forth from a country whose political leaders were eager to enact a federal law or even a Constutional amendment to make it a criminal offense to burn the American flag (which, using this parlance, is “just a piece of cloth”). In fact, before the Supreme Court struck down such statutes as unconstitutional in 1989 by a 5-4 vote, it was a crime in 48 states in the nation to burn the flag. Here is what Chief Justice William Rehnquist wrote in dissent about why the Constitution permits the criminalization of flag burning (emphasis added):

The American flag, then, throughout more than 200 years of our history, has come to be the visible symbol embodying our Nation. It does not represent the views of any particular political party, and it does not represent any particular political philosophy. The flag is not simply another “idea” or “point of view” competing for recognition in the marketplace of ideas. Millions and millions of Americans regard it with an almost mystical reverence, regardless of what sort of social, political, or philosophical beliefs they may have.

Might one say the same for Muslims and the Koran? Along those lines, just imagine what would happen if a Muslim army invaded the U.S., violently occupied the country for more than a decade, in the process continuously killing American children and innocent adults, and then, outside of a prison camp it maintained where thousands of Americans were detained for years without charges and tortured, that Muslim army burned American flags — or a stack of bibles — in a garbage dump. Might we see some extremely angry protests breaking out from Americans against them? Would American pundits be denouncing those protesters as blinkered, primitive fanatics?

Follow Glenn Greenwald on Twitter: @ggreenwald.More Glenn Greenwald

, , , ,

  • Pingback: Anti-Muslim and Faux Liberal Sam Harris to Debate Dr. Robert Pape Soon? | Islamophobia Today eNewspaper

  • Leia

    interesting take on the quran burning, by an American Jewish Lady, who uses empathy.
    http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/wolf45/English
    although we know these things happen, and are perpetrated by the US, the ‘fairest and free-est’ nation of the world it still shocked me to hear of the torture done in Bagram, the place where the Quran burning took place. as this author says this protest is a build up of so many things, and the burning of the revered books of a people is so little away from killing, oppressing, and torturing the people.when you strip away a people’s dignity, you have already committed an act of opression.

  • khushboo

    noob, let me direct you to Gotcha:

    “Civilized men don’t piss on dead bodies or INVADE other lands for OIL and resources, kill children and BOMB villages, you skinny filth. Why should Muslims show you any mercy after advocating Western terrorism? Start carpet bombing? The most EVIL government on earth is the US government, it slaughtered its own citizens on 9/11. Israel sent a group of Israelis to document the event KNOWING it would happen.

    The Quran doesn’t support terrorism, which is targeting of women and children (non-combatants), it forbids terrorism by saying to fight FOR women and children (4:75), to PROTECT holy places of worship (Q. 22:40) and fight ONLY in self-defense (2:190).

    And what is [the matter] with you that you fight not in the cause of Allah and [for] the oppressed among men, women, and children who say, “Our Lord, take us out of this city of oppressive people and appoint for us from Yourself a protector and appoint for us from Yourself a helper?” (4:75)

    AND FIGHT in God’s cause against those who WAGE WAR AGAINST YOU, but do not commit aggression-for, verily, God does not love aggressors. (2:190)

    The US/Israel/UK has waged WAR against the Muslim World, so the Muslims are following the Quran’s command to FIGHT BACK. Does Gellar support self defense?!

    (They are) those who have been expelled from their homes in defiance of right,- (for no cause) except that they say, “our Lord is Allah.. Did not Allah check one set of people by means of another, there would surely have been pulled down monasteries, churches, synagogues, and mosques, in which the name of Allah is commemorated in abundant measure. (Q. 22:40)

    Allah forbids you not, with regard to those who fight you not for (your) Faith nor drive you out of your homes, from dealing kindly and justly with them: for Allah loveth those who are just. (Q. 60:8)

    But if the enemy incline towards peace, do thou (also) incline towards peace, and trust in Allah. for He is One that heareth and knoweth (all things) (Q. 8:61)

    The “violent passages” of the Quran are ripped out of context, just as Christians took the Bible OUT OF CONTEXT to justify oppression of the Jews.

    Kill our soldiers and citizens? The soldiers are invaders, not civilians. Israel kills AMERICAN CITIZENS in Palestine and Muslims have NOT KILLED any American citizen, the only “example” is 9/11 for those brainless idiots who believe the government story. 9/11 was actually done by the US and Israel Mossad, not Muslims.

    Where are Muslim apologies for 1,400 years of jihadi wars, land appropriations, cultural annihilations and enslavements?

    RESPONSE:

    Where are your apologizes for centuries of Christian wars and European colonizations of the world, the slaughter of the Native Indians and killing of over 500,000 Iraqi children from sanctions? You have destroyed other people’s cultures for Christianity, destroying mosques after conquering Spain under Ferdinand and Isabella, yet Churches in the Muslim World are preserved to this day. Everything you say backfires on you!”

  • http://nb2dblogger.blogspot.com/ nb2d

    Hypocrites – Burn the Bible & Torah, destroy Christian Churches and Jewish house of worship, kill with impunity Christians and Jews. Now the world of Islam wants me and the world to believe that once again they are the victims. The ongoing mass murder of shia and sunni by each other is acceptable even if it is a funeral, wedding, school is somehow excuseable in the world of Islam. An apology from Obama and we all know that is something new is not acceptable not a word about the many deaths of US and other as a result of this typical over reaction.

Powered by Loon Watchers