Robert Spencer

|

Pamela Geller

|

Bat Ye'or

|

Brigitte Gabriel

|

Daniel Pipes

|

Debbie Schlussel

|

Walid Shoebat

|

Joe Kaufman

|

Wafa Sultan

|

Geert Wilders

|

The Nuclear Card

A Journey Out of Islamophobic Darkness

Posted on 23 April 2012 by Ilisha

islamophobia-drfus

Leaving the Islamophobia nightmare

The Islamophobia propaganda machine has its roots in years of concerted online, media and marketing campaigns. This well oiled machine of hate has attracted many followers, and they can be broken up into several groups (there may be considerable overlap):

1.) Those who were ripe for the picking. These individuals already had a hate for Islam and Muslims or Arabs, they were already racist in one way or another, and easily attached themselves to Islamophobia.

2.) Opportunists. These individuals are always looking for a way to make a buck, to line their pockets. Real, honest work doesn’t suit their tastes and so they’ve devoted themselves to that centuries old money-maker, hate.

3.) True believers. They may come from various ends of the ideological spectrum, most of them are very afraid, fear courses through their every waking moment, they are made even more afraid by modern interpretations of say Biblical prophecies, or fears about the existential threat of the end of Western society.

4.) The gullible or the naive. These individuals read and believe the Islamophobic propaganda because they perceive the arguments as objective, factual, honest, and fitting with their worldview, or answering their confusion and incomprehension of world events or history.

There may be a few other groups not identified here, but those in the last category, the “gullible or the naive,” are usually individuals who later become enlightened and realize the true nature of Islamophobia. They start to question the poor “analysis,” the skewing of “facts,” the blindly subjective and hateful methodology employed by those they once respected as honest brokers on the issues of Islam and Muslims.

One such individual is Charles Johnson. Loonwatch documented his groundbreaking and public quarrel with his former allies, JihadWatch’s Robert Spencer and Pamela Geller of AtlasShrugs. For Johnson it was their too easy comfort and alliance with fascists like Geert Wilders that broke the proverbial camel’s back, and ever since, he has been outspoken in his criticism of Islamophobes.

Their have been many like Johnson, some who have changed their minds because of our site or their own introspection. One such individual is regular Loonwatch commenter and tipster CriticalDragon. CriticalDragon was quite involved with right-wing anti-Muslim sites, respected the leading lights of Islamophobia, and even commented (under a different screen name) on Jihad Watch amongst other blogs.

We asked CriticalDragon to tell us about how he at one time embraced Islamophobia, and how and why he eventually left the quagmire of hate:

LW: What first attracted you to the “counter-jihadists?”

CD: Prior to 9/11, I was naive and had an overly simplistic and overly positive view of my country and the world. It’s not that I thought that America had done no wrong, but I believed that in every war since World War II, its intentions were noble.

I always considered myself an anti-bigot, which was ironic since I would become a bigot myself. Although I wasn’t as bad as some of the Islamophobes out there, I said and supported some things that I’m now really ashamed of. One of the reasons why I fell for the “counter jihadists” may have been in part because prior to 9/11, I didn’t hear much about anti-Muslim bigotry.

I did however have a very black and white view of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. I got most of my information on that from people like Rush Limbaugh. Although I wouldn’t call Rush an Islamophobe, he always portrayed the Palestinian side as evil. However, he did not make a connection between the conflict and Islam.

Right after 9/11 occurred, I wanted to find out why we were attacked. What had America done to deserve such an attack in their eyes, and why were they so willing to die to hurt us?

I knew about suicide bombers in Israel, but I really knew that I didn’t understand what motivated them either, but I didn’t think much about it, because I was not involved in the Israeli/Palestinian conflict. It didn’t affect me much, or anyone I knew, but now I felt that my country was in danger of being attacked again at any moment. I became aware shortly after the event of the fact that the 9/11 hijackers were Muslims, but I did not connect the two until later.

Searching for answers I came across the “counter Jihad blogs.” I can’t remember if the first one I came across was Jihad Watch or another one, but at some point I reached Jihad Watch. I read it and some other relatively moderate “Counter Jihad” blogs and basically believed everything I read without doing enough research to determine if they were true or not. For a while I assumed that what they were saying did not apply to most Muslims, and tried, but not hard enough, to find some peaceful liberal Muslims who denounced terrorism.

Even after visiting those sites I probably wouldn’t have bought into the Stealth Jihad or Population Jihad conspiracies if not for two events.

First, I assumed that after we overthrew the Taliban, the government in Afghanistan would be a genuine liberal democracy with religious freedom. At the time, and even though I believed people like Spencer in regards to what they presented as the “teachings of Islam” (death to the infidels, lying to the infidels, oppressive theocracy), I assumed most Muslims did not follow such “teachings.” But after the war was over, I remember an Afghan man who was set to be put to death for converting from Islam to Christianity, and it not only disappointed me, it kind of shocked me.

I literally believed what George W. Bush said about people wanting to live in freedom, and the Afghan people had chosen to install a government without freedom of religion, even after living under a brutal theocracy, and it seemed to me that we had even encouraged it to some degree.

Second was the cartoon riots, which really scared me, because it looked like large numbers of Muslims around the world spontaneously erupted over harmless cartoons, and I saw what looked like Western governments caving-in to their demands.

LW: Which Islamophobic blogs did you frequent?

CD: Mostly The Infidel Blogger’s Alliance, Bosch Fawstin, Citizen Warrior, FrontpageMag, Culturism, and Religion of Peace, which is the worst of them all. It literally scared me, every time I visited it.

They’re really deceptive in how they cherry pick news stories and post hundreds of terrifying stories about Islam and Muslims to support their agenda.

I might suggest that Loonwatch take the “Religion of Peace” website to task more often, except most of the stuff on there isn’t written by them. Most of it is just links to articles on other websites.

Although I read at least two of Robert Spencer’s books I did not spend a lot of time at Jihad Watch. I may have admired him at the time but I didn’t spend much time on his blog. The same is true for Pamela Geller and her Atlas Shrugs blog. One of the reasons why I didn’t realize how nuts she was may well have been because I didn’t spend much time there.

If you are going to take on one of the Islamophobic bloggers whose blog I used to follow I would recommend laying the smack down on Citizen Warrior. He’s kind of like Robert Spencer, but maybe a bit more sophisticated, although he hasn’t written any books that I’m aware of.  You might also want to take on John Kenneth Press (AKA Culturist John) who wrote the book Culturism, and runs the blog by the same name, and eviscerate some of his arguments, although he usually doesn’t deal with Islam or Muslims.

LW: You’ve mentioned in your comments that you truly believed in the threat of “stealth jihad.” Were there any other major themes that seemed to make sense to you at the time?

CD: I’m really embarrassed to say this, but after reading Marks Steyn‘s America Alone, I actually became convinced that Muslims in Europe were having far more children than non-Muslims, and given enough time, they would become the majority. I believed they would most likely turn those countries into Islamic theocracies, because at the time, that’s what I thought most of them wanted, or they wouldn’t be willing to resist when the fanatics started taking over.

I thought it might take centuries but still it scared me, the idea that these people with such an alien worldview might destroy Western culture and eventually replace it with Sharia’. I know its stupid, but I wasn’t thinking too hard at the time unfortunately.

Note that I never saw this in racial terms, always cultural terms. I was Islamophobic, but I was not a racist. I believed that Muslims in the West were raising their children in such a way that they would not share our values. It was not something genetic, but rather how I thought they were raising their children.

I also believed that the West was at war with Islam, yet simultaneously did not believe that all Muslims were evil, or even our enemies. I know that’s a contradiction, but I didn’t think about it too much at the time. On the occasions when other people would bring that up, I just rationalized it away. However, the fact that I realized that not all Muslims could be evil, would eventually help bring me out of the Islamophobic nightmare.

LW: For how long were you a regular visitor to the “counter-jihadist” blogs?

CD: Sadly, I was a follower and supporter of “counter jihad” blogs for about ten years following 9/11. I only really stopped being an Islamophobe some time in late September of 2011, and even then it would be another month or two before I completely rejected all their nonsense. For example I was still somewhat suspicious of CAIR until I realized that just about every blog that suspected them of being connected to terrorist groups like Hamas, recommended Jihad Watch and by that time I had come to see Robert Spencer as the bigot and liar that he really is.

LW: About Ten Years? Why did it take you so long to see the light?

CD: I got scared and I did not do a very good job of questioning what I was told. I was terrified, and I wanted to stop Jihadists from destroying our freedom. It seemed so obvious to me, because I was getting such a distorted picture of reality.

Early on when I joined the counter jihad movement, most of the information I was getting on what was going on in the world involving Islam and Muslims was incredibly biased to say the least, and I did not try very hard to critique it, because all the evidence seemed so overwhelming at the time. Most of the blogs I frequented outside of the “Counter Jihad Movement” rarely mentioned Islam or Muslims. I occasionally, though rarely, visited left wing political blogs.

One of the few exceptions was American United for the Separation Of Church and State, but I don’t even think they talked about Islam until people in the states started trying to pass anti-Shariah legislation. I spent the vast majority of my time on right-wing Islamophobic blogs, and my preferred news channel was Fox News, which rarely debunked Islamophobes. For those reasons, I almost always saw what left wing bloggers wrote refuting Islamophobic claims through the eyes of Islamophobes, and I rarely heard about Muslims protesting evil done in the name of their faith.

However, if I had been willing to do a bit more research to see what groups like Act For America really based their opposition on, outside of the Islamophobic blogs I frequented I would have seen just how wrong they were. In addition I was too quick to dismiss arguments against their positions.

There were some skeptical science blogs and YouTube channels that I really enjoyed, and they tended to be rather left wing, but they rarely mentioned Islam, that is until the idea of Everybody Draw Muhammad day and the issue of the “Ground Zero Mosque” came up, which was years after 9/11 and the cartoon riots.

Even then, too often, I tended to just dismiss them unless I already agreed with them. I got to the point where I really did not want to admit I was wrong. Maybe I didn’t want to admit I was being a bigot.

Case in point, when atheist YouTuber and foe of creationists everywhere, “Thunderf00t” came out in support for Everybody Draw Muhammad day, and made at least one anti “Ground Zero Mosque” video, I tended to dismiss the arguments that other, better, Youtuber skeptics made against him.

I admired “ThunderF00t,” for his strong stance for science and reason and against the “backwardness of Islam.” Ironically I would eventually come to respect and admire the people on YouTube who opposed him like Coughlin 666 (now Coughlin 616 and Coughlin 000) and Ujames1978 (now Ujames1978Forever and Pirus The God Slayer).

I was a horrible skeptic to say the least. For a long time I fell for just about every single prominent Loon.

I believed most of the things that they said, and it seemed like there were just so many “former Muslims” out there talking about how “evil” Islam is, and how the West was destined to be Islamized if we did not do anything to stop it, because there were just so many fanatical Muslims out there determined to force us to convert or submit. I used to really admire Wafa Sultan and, although I thought Walid Shoebat‘s fundamentalist Christian beliefs were a bit nonsensical to say the least, I never doubted that he really was a “former Muslim terrorist” until much later.

I had managed to entrap myself in my own nightmarish digital web of Islamophobia.

LW: What effect, if any did self-proclaimed Muslim supporters of Robert Spencer, such as Zuhdi Jasser have on you?

CD: They actually encouraged me to support the “counter jihad movement” early on and likely contributed to my own Islamophobia, but ironically and counter-intuitively they also were one of the factors that prevented me from seeing all Muslims as the enemy.

Let me explain.

By doing the things that he did, such as being the host of the Clarion Fund‘s anti-Muslim propaganda film, “The Third Jihad,”Jasser likely convinced a lot of people that there really was a conspiracy among American Muslims to “Islamize” the country. Some Islamophobic websites link to his organization, the “American Islamic Forum for Democracy,” and they use it as a way of claiming that they’re not really bigoted against Muslims because some Muslims support them and vice versa.

This certainly reinforced all of my fears, but at the same time, since I couldn’t come up with what I thought would be a good reason for him to be lying about this, it encouraged me to think that not all Muslims were bad. In fact, he was one of the few Muslims that I was certain was not lying to me.

Ironically, I didn’t lose respect for Jasser even while other anti-Muslim bigots tried to convince me that he was really a Stealth Jihadist as well. The only thing that made me completely lose respect for him was something he did after I left the “anti-jihad” movement, when he made a video defending Lowes at the moment they gave into intimidation and pressure from anti-Muslim bigots to drop support for the show “All American Muslim.” I was no longer an Islamophobe at that point and was in fact trying to fight anti-Muslim bigotry.

I’m not sure if Jasser is a “self hating Muslim” for lack of a better term, but he may be a useful idiot for Islamophobes. I have come across multiple instances where Islamophobes accused him of being a Stealth Jihadist as well, just because he’s a Muslim, they think he is lying to them and that he really supports groups like AlQaeda. What he and his organization are doing is perpetuating baseless conspiracy theories about Muslims, and he won’t convince Islamophobes who are already convinced that he’s the enemy that he’s a friend.

In fact, if he ever comes to see how baseless the Stealth Jihad conspiracy really is, and turns around and stops supporting “counter jihadists,” then a bunch of people who used to support him will become  convinced that he really was a stealth Jihadist all along.

LW: What changed your mind? Was it a single event or a process over time?

CD: It was a process, but there were some definite events.

I recall these events not in any particular order:

Even before 9/11, I considered myself a conservative, but I had some views that were not stereotypical of a conservative. For one thing I was a supporter of the separation of Church and State. I considered myself a secularist and a skeptic. I may have rightfully rejected things like scientific creationism, but a good skeptic would never have fallen for someone like Spencer or Geller, or if they had, they would have had too many doubts as soon as they started talking about things like the Stealth Jihad, or learned that they had their “scholarly” work published in the same series of books that promoted creationism and other forms of pseudoscience.

When I learned that Spencer’s, “the Politically Incorrect Guide to Islam and the Crusades,” had been published by the same people who published “The Politically Incorrect Guide to Darwinism and Intelligent Design,” it should have set off some red flags, but I had allowed myself to become too convinced that he was correct by then, and that he was a “real scholar.”

I was shocked when secularist groups like American’s United For the Separation of Church and State actually came out against the anti-Sharia’ legislation. I assumed they would support such laws, because in my mind it was fighting for secularism. The problem was that since I believed in those nonsensical anti-Muslim conspiracy theories, I actually believed that Muslim fanatics were a greater threat to our freedom than the religious right.

Like all bigots I was closed minded, but maybe not as closed minded as some. Part of the problem was that I was getting most of my information on Islam and Muslims from right-wing sources and they were incredibly biased. It made it look like there was a large number of Muslims out to take over the world. While I’m certain there are some blogs out there run by genuine right wing anti-loons, I didn’t come across too many. When I happened to come across a video debunking the claim that Muslims were likely to become the majority through immigration I began to doubt it for the first time.

Earlier, I came across another more “moderate critic” of Islam who went by the user name, “Klingschor.”  He started out as a supporter of Robert Spencer and at one time had favorited the ridiculous “Three Things You Probably Don’t Know About Islam” video on his YouTube channel.  However, as Klingschor got more educated, he eventually turned against Spencer. He created a video supporting the “Ground Zero Mosque,” and Imam Rauf, where he viciously attacked Spencer and Geller for being bigots.  (The video is no longer on his channel, although now I wish he’d repost the original or remake it).  I admired Spencer and Geller and I was convinced that Rauf was a “stealth jihadist,” so this shocked me, since I admired Klingschor as well and he didn’t seem pro-Islam to me. I wondered why he wasn’t convinced as I was that Rauf was up to no good and why he had suddenly turned on Spencer and Geller.  I had trouble explaining it.

In addition, I began to realize that if things did not change, a lot of innocent people were going to get hurt, and not by Muslim jihadists. I knew that not all Muslims were our enemies, and I would sometimes get into arguments with other people who held worse views than I did; people who wanted to nuke Mecca and kill every single Muslim on the planet.

Even when I pointed out to them how innocent people would be killed, it did not phase them. These nuke Mecca/kill all Muslims people were so bad that I saw them as anti-Muslim bigots even when I was an anti-Muslim bigot. That’s how bad they were.

Then something else happened, something that was somewhat of a watershed moment.

Most people in the “counter Jihad movement” assumed Anders Breivik was a Muslim when news of his rampage first came out. I was not really that shocked by the fact that he was not a Muslim, since I knew non-Muslim terrorists existed, but I was shocked by his motive.

He went on his rampage and murdered innocent people including many children, believing it was necessary to stop the Islamization of Europe. Of course excuses were made for Spencer and Geller not being responsible, and I bought into them at first, but the more I thought about it, the more I realized that their rhetoric did nothing to discourage a Breivik.

Even if Breivik got his beliefs from somewhere else, he idolized Spencer and Geller and was an avid supporter, not to mention other prominent figures in the “counter Jihad Movement.” If anything, they encouraged his behavior even if they did not specifically tell him to commit violent acts.

It was also about this time that I found out that a couple of the lesser known Islamophobes that I admired were racists.  No one you’ve probably heard of, just a couple of nobodies really, but I had admired them and thought they were smarter than they actually were. This was another shock to my system because I had really respected them, and I had always regarded racism as abhorrent and stupid. I instantly lost respect for them.

Plus I saw a video by Coughlin 616, called “Pamela Geller Busted.” Although at the time I thought he was wrong to oppose Geller and believed he was far too concerned with neo-Nazis as compared to Jihadists, I decided to watch the video. After watching it, and checking Coughlin’s sources, I realized that he had proven that Geller was a liar. What’s more she might have been covering for Breivik or someone like him. I suddenly had a lot more respect for Coughlin and a lot less respect for Geller.

In the meantime, I saw more videos by Klingscor, and another Youtube atheist critic of Islam, CEMBadmins, that actually debunked some common Islamophobic claims. One of them was taqiya, both of them made videos on the subject thoroughly debunking the claim that taqiya is lying for Islam and that Muslims are more likely to lie than non Muslims.

CEMBadmins really made it hard for me to continue to believe in the taqiya conspiracy since he was not only a critic of Islam, but an ex-Muslim. In his video, he talked about a poll taken of members of the Council of Ex-Muslims (his organization) and it turned out that most of them had never even heard of taqiya, and those that had regarded it as a defensive mechanism to protect themselves from persecution, not lying to promote Islam like I had been taught by others in the “counter jihad movement.”

I thought to myself, “Why would ex-Muslims lie for Islam?” It slowly began to hit me just how wrong people like Spencer were on the subject.

Soon, I saw a couple of videos on Muslims who helped save Jews during the Holocaust. At least one of them I came across on Loonwatch. Although I always knew there were at least some rare instances when Muslims helped non Muslims, I had no idea that so many Muslims had done so much at one time to help a large group of non-Muslims. I was slowly realizing just how much the evil done by Muslims to non Muslims like myself in the name of Islam was exaggerated by people in the “counter jihad movement,” and how much they ignored the good done by Muslims in the name of Islam.

The final nail in the coffin for my support for those “counter jihad” blogs and Spencer and Geller was when I realized that Islam has not traditionally endorsed terrorism.  When I found Loonwatch and looked at the actual statistics for the first time I realized that very few terrorists in the United States and Europe were even Muslims.

I came to realize just how wrong I was, and I felt an odd combination of happiness and relief as well as guilt and shame, simultaneously.

LW: Why do you spend so much time trying to help fight anti-Muslim bigotry now?

CD: For one thing, ever since I allowed myself to see the light, I have come to realize just how wrong I was. I’ve come to see that the people I once admired and supported like Geert Wilders are actually a greater threat to our freedom than the threat they claim to be fighting.

Since Stealth Jihad and Islamization are myths, there’s no need for any legislation to fight them. If anything, a lot of innocent people are going to be hurt by “counter jihadists” including innocent Muslims and non-Muslims alike, and for what? To fight imaginary conspiracy theories?

Also, the Christian religious right is more likely to turn America into a theocracy. With Muslims at less than one percent of the American population, they don’t have the numbers to do so, even if they all wanted to. In fact, I now understand that as someone who normally wouldn’t support the religious right, by trying so hard to fight the imaginary threat of Islamization, I made myself a useful idiot of the religious right. The same is true for any secularist who supports them out of fear of Jihadists taking over and turning the West into an Islamic theocracy.

Finally, I want to make up for the mistake of supporting the “counter jihadists.” The only way I can clear my conscious now is to actively oppose the people and organizations I once endorsed. I feel a lot of guilt, I did and said a lot of things that I regret now.

LW: Do you have any suggestions for those who still admire bloggers like Robert Spencer and Pamela Geller?

CD: If you want to hear people criticize Islam, look for people who are not bigots, and do not believe in nonsensical conspiracy theories, like “the stealth Jihad.” Make sure they reject the idea that Islam teaches Muslims to lie to promote their faith and that Muslims are more likely to lie than non Muslims. Find people who are at least trying to be objective and who avoid making sweeping generalizations about Muslims.

Also listen to what Muslims have to say about themselves, their politics, their philosophy and their faith. In many cases it will be completely counter to the negative stereotypes. Let me use someone who appears on Loonwatch from time to time as an example.

When I first saw “Dawah Films”  respond to “Thunderf00t,” I saw it only through the eyes of “Thunderf00t.” I thought he was threatening to kill him for criticizing his religion, but when I actually watched other videos he made, and talked to him about it, years later, I realized how radically different his motives actually were. Contrary to the way “Thunderf00t” portrayed him, he supported free speech and he even defended another YouTuber, “ZOMGitscriss,” against death threats from genuine Muslim extremists, when she made some minor criticisms of Islam.

In addition to listening to Muslims and moderate, rational critics of Islam, you should also take an Islamic Studies course at an accredited university, if you have the time. I’m hoping to do that, since contrary to what I used to believe, I don’t know much about Islam, and if I’m going to fight anti-Muslim bigotry, I’m going to have to know more about Islam and its history. If you can’t do that, or even if you can do that, in addition, try to find a few books about Islam written by genuine scholars who studied Islam within academia.

LW: How did you find Loonwatch?

CD: I believe I first heard about Loonwatch on a conservative blog that I used to visit from time to time.

The person behind the blog wrote a story critiquing something you wrote, but I don’t remember if I read it or not, but either way, I didn’t check his sources, so I didn’t find out what Loonwatch was until much later, after I left the “counter Jihad” movement.

After I stopped being an Islamophobe, I wanted to fight anti-Muslim bigotry and I started looking around and I came across Loonwatch and its sister site, SpencerWatch. However, I did notice that “Dawah Films” recommends you guys on his channel, but I can’t remember if I clicked on his link before or after I did a Google search.

LW: Do you regularly visit any other anti-bigotry sites, and if so, which ones?

CD: I really think the Southern Poverty Law Center is an excellent resource, especially if you include their blog “HateWatch.” The anti-Defamation League is also generally a good anti-bigotry organization. I know the American Civil Liberties Union does not specialize in fighting bigotry, but they do a very good job of protecting civil liberties including the civil liberties of minorities. More recently I started exploring Sheila Musaji’s “The American Muslim,” which also does a good job debunking anti Muslim myths as well.

I’d also recommend more than a few Youtube channels that have done a lot to fight irrational hatred and bigotry. I’ve already mentioned Coughlan and Ujames1978Forever’s channels, and would like to add EvoGenVideos and HannibaltheVictor13. EvoGenVideos is a genetics student who sometimes uses his scientific knowledge to debunk racists. HannibaltheVictor13 is an anthropologist who has also debunked racists.

LW: Is there any meaning behind your nickname, Critical Dragon1177, that you’d like to share?

CD: When I realized how wrong I was to support the “counter Jihad” movement, I also realized that I had said some incredibly stupid and often bigoted things that I was ashamed of. Plus I wanted to disassociate from those bigoted anti-Muslim blogs that I used to visit.

In order to do what I wanted to do, I needed a new user name. I made a new years resolution to be a better skeptic.

I realized that the biggest reason that I fell for what Islamophobes were telling me, and continued to believe them for so long, despite the overwhelming evidence against what they were saying was my lack of critical thinking on the matter. My story is really about the danger of not thinking critically, and of giving into your emotions.

That’s where the first part of my user name comes from. I added ‘Dragon’ because I like fantasy, and I love fantasy creatures. The numbers were added just in case someone else had that name.

LW: In conclusion is there anything else you would like to share with the LW audience?

CD: I’ve read a book called A World Without Islam that I highly recommend. It’s by Graham E. Fuller.

According to his biography over at Amazon.com,

“Graham E. Fuller is a former vice chairman of the National Intelligence Council at the CIA, a former senior political scientist at RAND, and a current adjunct professor of history at Simon Fraser University. He is the author of numerous books about the Middle East, including The Future of Political Islam. He has lived and worked in the Muslim world for nearly two decades.”

In his book, “A World without Islam,” Fuller goes a long way to debunk the claim that we are at war with Islam, and that Islam is the cause of terrorism and our problems involving Muslims and Muslim majority societies.

I haven’t read any of his other books, but based on this one, he’s largely anti Robert Spencer, and he has far better credentials than him. In fact if I had read something like this book just after 9/11 instead of going to all those bigoted “counter jihad” sites, I don’t think I would have taken people like Spencer seriously at all.

It was recommended to me by my friend, Klingschor, along with another book by Tamim Ansary called “Destiny Disrupted: A History of the World Through Islamic Eyes,” which I’ve started reading as well.

I also have a friend on Youtube that I would like to introduce, he goes by the user name, Ramio1983. He’s made at least one video fighting anti-Muslim bigotry, and I think he’s working on another one, maybe someone here could help him.

LW: Thank you, CriticalDragon, for sharing your story here on Loonwatch, and for joining the fight against bigotry.

CD: You’re Welcome.  I’m pleased to be able to share my story.  My hope  is that it will help someone else to see the truth.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @Garibaldi

    Thanks

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @Heinz Catsup

    Well like I mentioned in the interview it would be very difficult for Loon Watch to take on thereligionofpeace much more often than they do. The thing about Religion of peace that makes it so insidious is that whoever runs that blog rarely writes any of their own commentary. Most of the stuff over there is just links to other websites, even mainstream news sources sometimes which are cherry picked to support their agenda. Its easy to see how one who is as naive as I was, could fall for something like that, especially given 9/11 and many of the things followed it. But its also easy to see how it would be difficult to devote an entire blog or even a large portion of a blog that would be constantly updated to refuting them when most of the stuff there is not only not written by them, but isn’t even technically part of their site. Loon Watch or any other website devoted to fighting anti Muslim bigotry, or even bigotry in general might want to check thereligionofpeace for Islamophobic stories to refute through. That would be a good place to look for them. They post new ones every day, or at least they did when I frequented the site.

  • Garibaldi

    Good for you Critical, you have come a far way.

  • Heinz Catsup

    Like you said in the interview, I too would love it if Loonwatch would take on thereligionofpeace.com more often as well, even if it’s already known that the owner of the website is a racist ex-con with plenty of convictions at that who also denies the Srebrenica Genocide.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    By the way guys

    Here are the links to the other two channels I mentioned, in the interview in case you want to see them and you are having trouble finding them

    EvoGenVideos
    http://www.youtube.com/user/EvoGenVideos

    HannibaltheVictor13
    http://www.youtube.com/user/HannibaltheVictor13

    Also here are a couple more channels that I have come across that do a great job fighting bigotry, in particular they do a great job fighting anti Muslim bigotry.

    SamiZaatari
    http://www.youtube.com/user/SamiZaatari

    Anekantavad
    http://www.youtube.com/user/Anekantavad

    This last one in particular maybe doing a lot to help fight what Dianos refers to as “the Greater Islamophobia”

    Representative Press
    http://www.youtube.com/user/representativepress

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    By the way guys did I mention that Ramio1983 has a great sense of humor.

    He’s the one who made this video as well as many other Hilarious videos.

    My “Muslamic Ray Gun.”

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @Ramio1983

    Glad to hear from you. I was going to send you a PM over at youtube and tell you about this. I hope you get a lot more subscribers now as well as some more help fighting anti Muslim bigotry.

    I’m also interested in that new Youtube Muslim and atheist outreach program you just mentioned.

  • http://ramio1983.wordpress.com ramio1983

    Great article and thank you so so much…yes i have done half a dozen anti islamophobe videos and am currently active in a youtube muslim and atheist outreach program. Salam.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @JZ

    I don’t know if you’ll believe me, but I’m as real as anyone out there. In addition to the fact that it would be very hard for two different people to fake being the same person and leave comments on multiple blogs and fool even the experts would be almost impossible. In addition to the other blogs mentioned here I also leave comments on the Daily Kos from time to time under the name CriticalDragon1177, in addition to some other blogs like Skeptchick. Plus my opinions on one blog, rarely contradict what I wrote on another blog. Yeah, they’re going to be able to easily fake that by having two or me people pretending to be the same guy.

    Even if Loon Watch were to go to the trouble of making a fake ex Islamophobe, I’d bet they’d tell a better story than the one I did. If I really wanted to make it up, I could make it much more interesting sounding. Not to mention that much of my story is contrary to what many people would suspect.

    Also, last but not least, I do not speak for Loon Watch. Many of my comments on other websites have nothing to do with Islam, Islamophobia, anti Muslim bigotry, or anything ever mentioned on Loon Watch.

    Even so, Loon Watch has no need to make up fake ex Islamophobes, since we have the truth on our side. We don’t need to fake ex Islamophobes like Loons need fake ex Muslims or at least lying or extremely ignorant of their former religion ex Muslims like they need to sell their message.

  • Reynardine

    Actually, Rush Limbaugh is what we used to call a carbuncle on the buttock of humanity.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @Reynardine

    You wrote,
    ————————————————————————–
    Dragon, I want to say that your contributions both here and on Hatewatch are invaluable, and for you to have come this far from where you began is a remarkable achievement.
    ————————————————————————–

    Thank you. I also leave comments on other websites such as the Huffington Post. I signed up recently to leave comments on CNN’s website as well, but under the user name “cdragon1177,” CritialDragon1177 was too long for it, so it wouldn’t let me use that name, so I had to shorten it just for that website. I go by the name GargamelGold on Youtube. Sorry about the confusion with all the different names.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @Believing Atheist

    I’m glad to have you here as well. I’m a guy, just to let you know, so you don’t have to refer to me as he/she or his/hers when talking about me.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @JT,

    I can actually tell you the names of both of the videos I saw debunking the “Taqiyya is lying for Islam myth” that helped to change my mind if you want to see them.

    This is the one by Klingschor,

    Al-Taqqiyyah & Philhellenes DEBUNKED
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4hYzeqOCMvY&feature=plcp&context=C4d118d8VDvjVQa1PpcFPkqy4e-6wxxVihQTiPdLFQj_dXn4S4f10=

    And this is the one by CEMBadmins.

    Taqiyya & Abrogation
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SjZSJg1HQpc&feature=plcp&context=C4501247VDvjVQa1PpcFNO2Dyh50llroEdgabv52Esca-B_vgAMtM=

    Also, I think that this is the Poll CEMBadmins talked about in his video
    http://www.councilofexmuslims.com/index.php?topic=12625.0

    Note that I do not necessarily agree with everything else on their youtube channels. I seriously take issue with one of the channels that CEMBadmins recommends. Victimless Criminal is kind of Islamophobic to say the least, but oddly enough CEMBadmins himself has actually debunked some of the things on that channel. I would love to ask CEMBadmin’s himself about that, but he left youtube awhile ago.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @Solid Snake
    @Abbey

    You’re Both Welcome.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @Truth Seeker

    You Wrote,
    ———————————————————————–
    Every Muslim is a fearsome DRAGON which can be recognised only by islmophobes who fortunately have 20/20 vision.
    ———————————————————————–

    Are you a poe like Steven Colbert? If not, I hope you see the light someday as I have, and accept reality.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @Marco

    You Wrote,
    ————————————————————————-
    As muslims we believe, that guidance is in the hands of Allah – and that our only goal is to deliver the message.

    Thye keep claiming muslims can lie to promote Islam, i’d like them to bring a single example of Prophet Muhammad PBUH. or any of his companions later on, using deception to promote the message of Islam.

    Good on you for seeing the light dragon. Some people are so blinded by hate, they will never see the light, you were not one of them.

    Geller/Spencer and the rest of those hate mongers need to be exposed for what they are. This wohle movement needs to be exposed, so that one day they will be viewed in the same way as whtie surpemacists are seen today, and the likes of Geller/Spencer will be taken as seriously as David Duke
    ————————————————————————-

    Believe it or not, there’s even more to the story as to why I left the “counter Jihad” movement than what is written here. I mentioned a few more things in the original draft of the interviewer, however they had to take some of it out to cut down on the word count.

    In the original draft I mentioned an incident where the writer of one of the “counter jihad” blogs I visited found a man guilty of terrorism without a trail, and suggested they hold the suspect indefinitely despite the fact that he had not been tried, and how he wasn’t captured on the battle field so he was in no way a prisoner of war or an illegal enemy combatant. In fact the the guy was a citizen of the country he was being held in. The person who ran the blog basically, just assume he was guilty because he was a Muslim, and I realized that there was a good chance that he might be an innocent man, so I told him that. The blogger was certain that he was guilty despite the fact that the he had not been tried and he got angry at me for questioning his judgement.

    That was one of the things that eventually led me to realize what a mistake I made supporting the “counter jihad.”

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @Ahmed

    I never was a Muslim. I’m not really interesting in becoming a Muslim either, however, I’m not going to judge anyone who is a Muslim or decides to convert. Contrary to what Islamophobes out there think, there’s nothing about Islam that makes it any more inherently malevolent than any other religion, including the other Abrahamic faiths. People just need to accept that. Once everyone, or even almost everyone rejects the stealth jihad/creeping sharia conspiracy theory and the myth that Muslims are taught to lie to spread Islam, the average person living anywhere in the west will be just as likely to trust Muslims as anyone else.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @Sulayman F.

    You Wrote,
    ————————————————————————-
    What a great interview. As someone who feared Muslims post-9/11, I know exactly what you mean. Thank God I became Muslim, because seeing it from the perspective on the inside is quite different. Non-Muslims often assume that Muslims are a united front of monolithic culture and ideas that are bent on steamrolling over the “West” and that the rightwingers speak for all Muslims. From the inside, I realize that the Ummah is disjointed and diverse, and there are wonderful people who do astounding good deeds and never get the attention that extremists do.
    ————————————————————————-

    Its too bad that people who are Muslims who do good instead of Evil don’t get that much attention right now, compared to the violent fanatics, especially the ones that do evil in the name of their religion. People need to remember that Muslims are not all the same and that Islam is not a monolith. There is not one interpretation of even the Qur’an that is accepted by all Muslims, not to mention the split between Sunni and Shia, and the other sects of Islam.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    mindy1

    You Asked,
    ————————————————————–
    Feels good seeing the light, isn’t it
    ————————————————————–

    Actually yes and no. I feel great that I’m doing the right thing, and not having to worry about that nonsensical stealth Jihad conspiracy or fearing that someone I don’t know who happens to be a Muslim might be out to get me. However, I can’t help but feel bad for helping spread hatred, irrationality, and paranoia for so long.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @Jack Cope

    I agree. For an Islamophobe, Citizen Warrior does an excellent job of not appearing hateful and simultaneously appearing intellectual. One thing that’s really shocking, is that I think at least one or two people might have used his blog as a source who weren’t anti Muslim bigots, without realizing what they were doing. That’s one of the reasons I’m hoping that Loon Watch or some other anti bigotry organization will eventually take him on and expose him. Last time I checked, he also recommends an extremely paranoid anti Muslim blog called Logan’s Warning.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @HGG

    You Wrote,
    ———————————————————————–
    “Although I wouldn’t call Rush an Islamophobe, he always portrayed the Palestinian side as evil.”

    I wouldn’t call Rush an Islamaphobe, either. It’s way too reductive to describe the festering pus and bile that is Rush Limbaugh.

    Nice interview. I always enjoy Critical Dragon’s insights and posts.
    ———————————————————————–

    You’re Welcome, and you’ll be glad to know that I no longer have a very positive view of Rush Limbaugh either.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    @Muslim Heritage .com

    You Wrote,
    ————————————————————————-
    Welcome to the real world CriticalDragon, i’m glad you saw light.

    It’s my belief that the sea of ignorance (most Americans are poorly educated) is the reason they are able to be manipulated.

    I have said many times, freedom of speech is only workable with a sophisticated educated populace, otherwise opportunists move in to brainwash. We can see results of this in many Arab countries with dictators, who whilst looting their countries, propogate that they are compelled to do so by the USA or blame Israel.

    Like the ignorant Americans, these ignorants hold a lot of prejudiced beliefs based on lies and propoganda.

    This is the reason, the likes of Robert Spencer and Pamela Geller never had a following in Europe, whose population is better educated, and never swallowed the Islamophobia myth.

    Euro Islamophobes are either neo nazis or ultra Israel nationalists. Anders Brievik is one such example.

    Maybe now CriticalDragon can start an “Islamophobe who saw the light” club :)

    Seriously, you could educate others. The media would support you,
    ————————————————————————-

    I’m glad I saw the light as well, unfortunately it did take me far too long. If I had only done a better job of being a critical thinker and questioned things more and done more research, on places other than those biased “counter jihad” sites.

    while it is true that free speech can be misused to fool the gullible, I don’t really know what the solution to the problem is. Its not like we could educate all of America over night, and even far too many Europeans are ignorant or basing their decisions on emotions rather than reason.

    I Might start an “Islamophobe who saw the light” club, or even a webpage. But I don’t know if I’ll have the time to run it.

    You wrote,
    ———————————————————————–
    Thank you Loon Watch for this interview.

    Could you get one from Charles Johnson too?
    ———————————————————————–

    Believe it or not, in the original draft of this interview, I actually suggested that they interview Charles Johnson as well as Dawah Films, but they took that section out. I guess they needed to shorten it.

    You Wrote,
    ———————————————————————-
    It’s just as important that you see what is motivating Spencer (paid by Zionists), Geller and the ‘whole counter jihad’ movement. Ulitimately, they do have an aim, that is to lessen Muslim influence because they feel Islam stands in their way of the Likud agenda.

    It’s the rabid far right Zionism, where they conflate AMerica’s interests as being the same as Likud.

    Note how Geert Wilders, a one man politician wasn’t funded by Dutch, but by American neo cons, Daniel Pipes, a Jewish Likudnik and he has been to Israel over 40 times.

    They want to expand territory, but they cannot with a world that won’t allow it, so they need a threat to exploit to convince the world otherwise.
    ———————————————————————-

    I agree. People need to understand the true nature of the “counter jihad” movement. Its main aim is not what they say they it is and those that are a part of it, who think they really are defending freedom are delusional and paranoid, like I was. Not to mention the fact that they are actually helping people who want to take away freedom.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold?feature=mhee CriticalDragon1177

    Guys. I’m here! Now I’m going to respond to questions and comments the best I can. Sorry about the delay, but I had work to do and I wasn’t able to be here until now.

  • Reynardine

    Critical Dragon is not a fictitious person, but someone I encountered elsewhere before here. I am more capable than most of spotting inconsistencies in style and content that give away multiple writers; Dragon saw me do it on a different blog. This writer is a genuine person.

  • JT

    I absolutely love it when some fool from Jihadwatch comes on here and says “I know this comment won’t be posted because y’all hate freedom of speech” but lo and behold there it is.

    JZ, your comment shows why sensible, intelligent people are realising just how wrong Islamophobia is. Anything that contradicts your view of the world is dismissed as a lie or put down to a conspiracy theory. Rather than understand what the article is about, you instead decide to suggest — without evidence — that LW has nothing better to do than invent a massive article that shows someone’s journey out of Islamophobia. Because let me tell you, there is technically no need for LW to do anything — the writings of Islamophobes are just so wild and nonsensical, they really speak for themselves.

    Please take another look at what you’re buying into (quite literally considering the amount of money Spencer and Geller are making from gullible Islamophobes), and recognise that Muslims are human just like you and deserve the same rights. You’ll see that there is no Leftist-Muslim alliance, stealth jihad, demographic jihad, water jihad, soup jihad or whatever types of jihad have been invented since I stopped checking those websites. Who are you going to trust for information on Islam — Muslims and non-biased academics (those whom you term Leftist Dhimmis) or fake scholars like Robert Spencer?

Advertise Here
Advertise Here