Robert Spencer

|

Pamela Geller

|

Bat Ye'or

|

Brigitte Gabriel

|

Daniel Pipes

|

Debbie Schlussel

|

Walid Shoebat

|

Joe Kaufman

|

Wafa Sultan

|

Geert Wilders

|

The Nuclear Card

Pakistan: Rimsha Masih Freed, Blasphemy Debate Continues

Posted on 09 September 2012 by Ilisha

Rimsha

It’s wonderful news that Rimsha Masih has been released from jail in Pakistan.

Masih is an 11 year old Christian girl who was arrested under Pakistan’s blasphemy laws after she was falsely accused of burning the Quran. She and her family will remain in protective custody to ensure their safety.

One interesting point to highlight in the following article is that Pakistan’s blasphemy laws derive not from Sharia, but from Biritsh colonial laws, circa 1860. The looniest blogger ever, Pamela Geller, is frothing-at-the-mouth, telling her readers anyone reporting this unwelcome historical  fact is, “whitewashing Pakistan’s blasphemy laws,” including CNN.

Whatever the origin of Pakistan’s vile blasphemy laws, they urgently need to be repealed. Let’s hope this outrageous, high profile case will ultimately spark much needed reform.

In Pakistan, girl freed but blasphemy debate still stuck

By Taha Siddiqui, Christian Science Monitor

Pakistan released from jail a Christian girl accused of burning Muslim religious texts and flew her to an undisclosed location by government helicopter.

“Due to the security concerns surrounding her and the family, the girl is being kept in government’s protective custody and there are plans to settle them outside Islamabad,” says Tahir Naveed Chaudhry, one of her lawyers.

The courts had approved the girl’s bail on Friday at a sum of one million rupees (equivalent to $10,500), on the grounds of her being a minor. The accusations against the girl had also lost strength when it emerged that a local cleric had planted burnt pages of the Quran in the evidence, in order to evict Christians from the locality they were living in.

Activists seeking to reform Pakistan’s stringent blasphemy laws had hoped this case would spur public debate and government action toward amending the laws. However, that has not happened yet, say activists, and the girl’s release may cause the spotlight to fade.

“Even though we are happy that the child is now reunited with her parents, I am unhappy about the public face the government put on during the ordeal. The state did not come with any long term resolve to stop the abuse of blasphemy laws, and the debate does not even seem to go in that direction,” says Peter Jacob, head of one of the largest minority rights’ activist groups in Pakistan.

The blasphemy laws, which date back to the colonial times in South Asia, were carried forward in the constitution by Pakistani authorities after the country’s independence in 1947. In the 1980s, draconian amendments to the laws by a military dictator were introduced, to the extent that anyone found guilty of committing blasphemy can be punished for life, and in severe cases, with a death sentence.

“The text of the law has problems but even if that is changed, it is the mindset of society that needs to be changed,” says Marvi Sirmed, a social activist, who has been threatened many times over her strong secular views. “Until and unless the state divorces itself from religion, and becomes secular, persecution of minorities will continue to happen,” Ms. Sirmed adds…

Pakistan’s Christian community

Pakistan’s roughly 2.7 million Christians make up less than 2 percent of the population. The Christianity community here, both Catholic and Protestant, traces much of its roots back to missionary efforts during British rule of the Indian subcontinent…

Read the rest here

 

Related Stories: 

Pakistan: 11 Year Old Christian Girl, Rimsha Masih Arrested on Charges of Blasphemy

Pakistani mullah ‘planted charred texts’ on girl accused of blasphemy

Senior Islamic cleric defends Christian girl: “Our Heads are Bowed in Shame”

Mehdi Hasan: Not In My Name: Islam, Pakistan and the Blasphemy Laws

CAIR Calls for Release of Pakistani Girl Held for ‘Blasphemy’

  • Ethis

    Religions are ideologies. Why should they be above criticism? Blasphemy should of course be permitted. If you find any aspects of any religions bad, you should be able to criticise them. You may praise them if you like or be respectful. It’s upto you. You should have freedom of religious beliefs. One should be able to promote any religion they like, proselytize if they like. Convert people to different religions if they can (except by force) including by allurement. Why not? If someone has been allured to another religion you don’t like, you should have the freedom to allure him back. Double benefit for that guy. Why not? No one should be allowed to use force to prevent this basic (religious) freedom of man. It is the duty of the law machinery to ensure this. To protect the minorities including those people who are critical of ‘majority’ religions.

    Sentiments! To hell with it. Your freedom is much more important. Everyone has to learn to be a little thick skinned.

    More or less, one of the few countries I know where laws do provide for such freedom is USA.

    Frrreeeeeeedom!!!!!! It is lovely. Freedom is not just from the colonisers. Freedom of the spirit is also important. I love your freedom too. Please speak your mind. Just don’t threaten anyone with violence to keep quiet.

  • Xithurel

    @Ipso facto

    I’m Jewish, your logic is asinine.

  • Steve

    @AJ, “It seems very convenient to blame everything on Islam even when it is a crime against Muslims”

    If muslims commit a crime against muslims because they are different muslims then it might be worth a look at their reasons don’t you think? Given islam is considered by muslims to be complete and immutable why are there different muslims? A complete, immutable, religion laid down with total clarity can’t be misinterpreted or changed yet that has happened, why?

  • http://aayjay.wordpress.com AJ

    Ilisha,

    Good for us. Thanks.

    I was trying to be sarcastic with “it”. It seems very convenient to blame everything on Islam even when it is a crime against Muslims.

  • Ilisha

    @AJ

    It seems Ipso facto is a sock puppet and a troll we’ve seen before. He’s banned, and no more of his comments will be published.

  • http://aayjay.wordpress.com AJ

    “I will post links from Pak/ME online publications from events of the past week, including the 26 Shia kill and 50 plus injures in Parichinar, which show how morally depraved the region has become as political Islam mows it’s advance.”

    Do you know who is behind this terror plot? If so, I urge you to contact the authorities and let them know about it.

  • Ilisha

    @Ipso facto

    Funny how your jumped the gun, and your comment WAS published.

    “Yes, I am Western, so according to you I am responsible for “colossal crimes”.

    Where did I say you were personally responsible? I didn’t. I was responding to your comments about Muslims by drawing a parallel, and obviously you missed the point.

    Maybe I would answer for those who, “think it is their duty to harangue, harass and even kill those who insult their faith,” if I were one of them. I’m not.

  • http://Loonwatch Ipso facto

    @illisha

    Funny how my non-offensive post do nit get published. I will take that as a forfeit from the challenge I put forth.

  • http://Loonwatch Ipso facto

    @illisha

    Let’s try this little exercise, I will post links from Pak/ME online publications from events of the past week, including the 26 Shia kill and 50 plus injures in Parichinar, which show how morally depraved the region has become as political Islam mows it’s advance. I challenge you to find incidents of greater moral deparavity in the West. Care to wager that you will fail miserably in your attempt?

    You see, you and others at loon watch are more than likely open-minded moderate thinking people. The trouble is that these traits which are admirable in the West would in the least get you castigated in the Islamic world and possibly be an invitation for corporal harm done by the “defenders of the faith” who seem to think it is their duty to harangue, harass and even kill those who insult their faith.

    What type of deity needs mere humans to defend him/her/it? Is Islam so fragile that mere words can destroy it?

    Yes, I am Western, so according to you I am responsible for “colossal crimes”. That sounds so much like the Westerners about whom you complain that blame Islam for the crimes committed in it’s name. I guess that makes you a hypocrite.

    Well the challenge is there if you are up to it. The the truth speak for itself.

  • Ilisha

    @Ipso facto

    I didn’t justify anything, nor did we sweep this story under the rug. We posted numerous articles highlighting the plight of this girl and criticizing Pakistan’s blasphemy laws.

    However, I’m tired of Westerners standing on their imaginary moral high ground pointing fingers at Muslims while ignoring their own colossal crimes, however they’re justified. Pointing out double standards usually doesn’t absolve anyone, but rather indicts both sides–and that’s certainly true in this case.

  • http://Loonwatch Ipso facto

    @illisha

    I guess that is the difference between you and I. You try to justify a wrong with a wrong. This article has nothing to do with western militarism yet you try to use that as an excuse for and deflection from the abdominal levels of hatred that fundamentalists in Pakistan exhibit against Christians, Shia, Ahmadis and anyone else who disagrees with their warped world view. If you are not part of the solution you are part of the problem.

  • Ilisha

    “It must be hard being a Muslim with a conscience who tries to whitewash the actions of the ” fundamentalists” that are filled with blind rage.”

    It must be hard being a Westerner with a conscience who tries to whitewash extreme militarism and the constant resort war–which kills far more innocent people than terrorists could in their wildest dreams. It must be even tougher grappling with such staggering hypocrisy.

  • Ipso facto

    @Xithurel

    Healthly debate? You must be delusional, they had to helicopter her away with her family for their safety. It must be hard being a Muslim with a conscience who tries to whitewash the actions of the ” fundamentalists” that are filled with blind rage.

  • Xithurel

    Point for the Muslims in Pakistan. They saved one life they have saved humanity. Now they are engaging in a very rational debate – this is awesome.

  • Heinz Catsup

    Good news.

  • http://twitter.com/Raza_inc Razainc

    That is good to see

  • mindy1

    Oh thank god she is free, those laws are vile :D

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/GargamelGold CriticalDragon1177

    @Ilisha

    I’m so glad that Rimsha Masih is free now.

Advertise Here
Advertise Here