Robert Spencer

|

Pamela Geller

|

Bat Ye'or

|

Brigitte Gabriel

|

Daniel Pipes

|

Debbie Schlussel

|

Walid Shoebat

|

Joe Kaufman

|

Wafa Sultan

|

Geert Wilders

|

The Nuclear Card

[Open Thread Sunday] Benjamin Edetanlen Sentenced To 18 Years, Defends Killing Son With Bible Passage

Posted on 14 October 2012 by Emperor

An American man murders his child, an innocent, vulnerable human being and cites holy scripture as justification. If that man’s name was Abdullah or Mohamed it would receive wide media coverage and without a question would go viral in the Islamophobia echo chamber. Comments and discussion threads would be packed with those pontificating on Islam’s so-called “unique violent nature” and ironically would be accompanied by calls to exterminate Islam and Muslims.

Are we to expect Christian Americans to apologize on behalf of the actions of Benjamin Edetanlen? Should we demand marches and condemnations from American Christians? Should we be shouting about where the “moderate Christians” who condemn such atrocious actions are, and why they are so “silent?”

Of course Christianity and the Bible should not be blamed for the actions of Benjamin Edetanlen, but when are we going to see a similar shift in the rhetoric and framing of violent actions carried out by lone Muslims in the name of Islam?

In the following story, the opening line is “Clearly, he missed the ‘Thou shall not kill’ part.”

Now that is refreshing! But will we see a story about Muslims with the first sentence reading, “Clearly, he missed the ‘Killing a fellow human is like killing all of humanity, and saving a fellow human is like saving all of humanity part”?

I will add that the justification of killing a child with the verse, “spare the rod, spoil the child” is not new, we have covered it numerous times in the past when parents have used it as a means of corporal punishment. (h/t: JD)

via. Huffington Post

Clearly, he missed the “Thou shall not kill” part.

A Georgia father, sentenced Wednesday to 18 years for murdering his 5-month-old son, used a biblical verse to defend the fatal beating, the WSB-TV reports.

Benjamin Edetanlen said he was acting on the old adage, “Spare the rod, spoil the child.”

Assistant District Attorney Dalia Racine argued that Edetanlen used similar force on his other children, a 2-year-old daughter and a 1-year-old son.

“The defendant stated that he disciplined the children according to the book of Proverbs in the bible,” Racine said, according to Atlanta Journal-Constitution.

Though his son died from blunt force trauma, suffering brain injuries and a broken leg, Edentanlen’s attorney maintained the defendant’s faith in the passage.

“Mr. Edetanlen firmly believed in the adage, you know, spare the rod and spoil the child,” defense attorney Ingrid McGaughey said.

Edetanlen initially faced a murder charge, but instead pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter and child cruelty.

  • Ummer

    Imagine if this loonwatch ever mentioned an atheist or agnostic killer.

  • http://humanadvocatefoodbank.org/Home.html The Knocker

    @Pray4Malala
    Thanks for re-posting my comment on Huffpo. I would like to add that under no circumstances in any way wished to minimized the heinous act committed by Benjamin Edetanlen.

    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/social/The_Knocker/benjamin-edetanlen-sentence-bible_n_1961602_196150270.html

  • RDS

    “But will we see a story about Muslims with the first sentence reading, “Clearly, he missed the ‘Killing a fellow human is like killing all of humanity, and saving a fellow human is like saving all of humanity part”?”

    No, because that line is way too long and not as catchy as a headline. ‘Nuff said.

  • tarig

    I wonder how long until the fact he is Black is brought up by the Islamophobes, lets face it, they are as racist as they are bigots, its just not ‘cool’ to be anti-black.

  • mindy1

    @pray4malala, that is a good point. Regarding this man, I would like nothing more than to give him an enema of flesh eating bacteria

  • Garibaldi

    @Reynardine,

    Good point!

    Looks like Dominionism is on the march.

  • Reynardine

    Amazing how this item follows right on Charles aptly-named Fuqua’s book advocating stoning disobedient children to death, based on Scriptiure.

  • Averroes’ Ghost

    Don’t you know it is only when Muslim do the crime that there is any consequences and attributions are all to their religion Islam. Actually the Islamophobies probably see this and blame him because he is Black, though they hide such racism from the world because they are now scare to express it.

  • Pingback: Sentenced To 18 Years, Defends Killing Son With Bible Passage

  • Pray4Malala

    This comment from the link you provided on HuffingtonPost was excellent and especially noteworthy regarding events in Pakistan>
    “I find it very interesting that this story is not published in the Religion section, especially since its directly related to someone religious conviction based on an actually verse in the Bible.
    Above-all, the continues of plastering of the Taliban killing of 14 year old Malala is tribal and could never be substantiated using Quranic text. Amazingly, the Taliban could have justify their barbaric tradition much better by using the scriptural texts from the Bible.”

Advertise Here
Advertise Here