Top Menu

If you haven’t been Detained, you’ve been Deported


A new grave marker names the Mexicans who died in an airplane crash at Los Gatos in 1948.

The Islamophobia that is alive in this country – from the anti-Muslim legislation to the illegal spying by the NYPD – casts a wide net on Muslims, citizens and non-citizens, similarly to the way it is casted on immigrants. Recently, there was a ceremony at a California graveyard  for the 28 farm workers who were being deported back to Mexico, when in 1948, their plane crashed at Los Gatos.  Unfortunately, after the event, reporters only printed the names of the pilot, co-pilot, flight attendant and an immigration guard but not the Mexicans, the deportees in that plane. They were not recognized. Following this incident, Woody Guthrie penned a famous poem that would later be turned into a song titled Plane Wreck at Los Gatos (Deportee) in protest of the incident:
Some of us are illegal, and some are not wanted, Our work contract’s out and we have to move on; Six hundred miles to that Mexican border, They chase us like outlaws, like rustlers, like thieves. We died in your hills, we died in your deserts, We died in your valleys and died on your plains. We died ’neath your trees and we died in your bushes, Both sides of the river, we died just the same.
Fast forward in 2013, an editorial in the New York Times reminds us that  the treatment of deportees has not evolved one bit:
Mr. Obama speaks of embracing immigrants but has deported nearly two million of them. He and Ms. Napolitano, who left office last week, always said they were focused on catching dangerous criminals, but they cast a wide net that has fallen hard on day laborers, carwash employees, farm workers and others who pose no threat.
How sophisticated are immigration policies if the average working person is being targeted? How just are these policies if we acknowledge their labor but not their humanity? Take for example, The Strengthen and Fortify Enforcement Act, a bill that gives “state and local governments the authority to write and enforce their own immigration laws.” This type of authority has always been reserved as a foreign policy matter, not for local officers who will now turn these civil immigration violations into crimes. Immigration laws have largely been used as a tool to target communities, and we see this especially true in a post-9/11 world. Instead of deportees, there are detainees. David Cole’s Enemy Aliens provide haunting insight on this:
Immigration law has been the centerpiece of the preventive detention campaign. At every opportunity since September 11, Ashcroft has turned immigration law from an administrative mechanism for controlling entry and exist of foreign nationals into an excuse for holding suspicious person without meeting the constitutional requirements that ordinarily apply to the preventive detention.  – David Cole, Enemy Aliens
All though David Cole’s Enemy Aliens was published in 2003, this campaign has taken other forms; the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) is an extension of this campaign.  Obama signed the bill at the end of 2011, which includes sections 1021 and 1022. These sections give the government the power to detain not only immigrants but any American without due process. In other words, legal kidnapping. Both detainees and deportees are slapped with similar laws to limit their rights and deny their stay in  this country. Their denial is not based on any constitutional motives but rather a xenophobic culture that fears the other. The preventive detention campaign and the Strengthen and Fortify Enforcement Act both attack their target by using immigration law as the centerpiece. One may wonder what purpose does it serve to target certain communities. A lesson in history will show that immigration and economic woes, political turmoil or war has coincided. Here is  a  history of immigration in the US:
  • During the depression of the 1840s, mobs hostile to immigrant Irish Catholics burned down a convent in Boston and rioted in Philadelphia.
  • In 1882, Congress passed the Chinese Exclusion Act, one of our nation’s first immigration laws, to keep out all people of Chinese origin.
  • During the “Red Scare” of the 1920s, thousands of foreign-born people suspected of political radicalism were arrested and brutalized. Many were deported without a hearing.
  • In 1942, 120,000 Americans of Japanese descent had their homes and other property confiscated, and were interned in camps until the end of World War II. During the same period, many Jews fleeing Nazi Germany were excluded under regulations enacted in the 1920s.
  • In the 1950s, a government program targeted Mexicans, exclusively, for deportation.

The next bullet point would read: After  9/11,  government programs target Muslims, exclusively, for detainment. Detainees and deportees are in the same struggle. In a country built upon immigrants, we have a systematic way of stripping them of their rights and denying them of their humanity.

Anytime the rights of the alien, the immigrant, the foreigner has been stripped it has resulted in the stripping of the rights of the citizen. If the other is not protected, then the citizen is no longer protected. Or as Guthrie puts it, “Both sides of the river, we died just the same.”

The alien was to be protected, not because he was a member of one’s family, clan, religious community, but because he was a human being. In the alien, therefore, man discovered the idea of humanity. – Herman Cohen, Opening quote used in Enemy Aliens

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

    • GaribaldiOfLoonwatch

      Nice article, always good to see Woody Guthrie mentioned.

    • CriticalDragon1177

      I wish I knew. Other than doing a better job of teaching history, I don’t know much else. Maybe we could use some of the strategies to reduce bigotry, used in the SPLC’s teaching Tolerance Program?

    • Yausari

      That’s a disturbing conclusion. What can be done?

    • Talking_fish_head

      Unfortunatly, as long as people profit from these things it will continue, they’ll sell ad revenue on TV warning people about the “Big Brown Menace” to sell security cameras and hire more people to watch for “Scary Brown people” at airports and train stations.

    • CriticalDragon1177

      Sad but true. At one point there was wide spread discrimination against Catholics in the country, yet today one of our most prominent anti Muslim hate Mongers is Robert Spencer, who is a Catholic. Same is true for Jews, except even more so, and we all know about the horrors of the Holocaust, but there are plenty of Jewish Islamophobes out there.

      For all we know we know, after all the Islamophobia has died down, a Muslim maybe a prominent propagandist in the next major wave of persecution of a minority group in America.

    • mindy1

      *sigh* and time marches on… most reasonable people want reform, but it’s hard to find an answer that satisfies everyone…what should be done and what can be done?

    • mindy1

      Hard to say-last years victim may become tomorrows oppressor if he gets rich and feels threatened :/

    • CriticalDragon1177


      When will we ever learn from history and stop repeating it?

Powered by Loon Watchers