Top Menu

France Begins Jailing People For Ironic Comments

France begins jailing people for ironic comments


Mock Charlie Hebdo cover circulated after the murder of the magazine’s cartoonists. The text says “Charlie Hebdo is shit. It doesn’t stop bullets.”

It may sound like an ironic joke, but it isn’t. Less than a week after the massive rallies in defense of “free expression,” following the murders of the Charlie Hebdo cartoonists, French authorities have jailed a youth for irony.

The arrest is part of a harsh crackdown on free speech in the country that has prompted criticism from national and international human rights organizations.

A 16-year-old high school student was taken into police custody on Thursday and indicted for “defending terrorism,” national broadcaster France 3 reports.

His alleged crime? He posted on Facebook a cartoon “representing a person holding the magazine Charlie Hebdo, being hit by bullets, and accompanied by an ‘ironic’ comment,” France 3 states.

The teen lives at home with his parents, has no prior judicial record and, according to prosecutor Yvon Ollivier quoted by French media, he does not have a “profile suggesting an evolution toward jihadism.”

The boy told prosecutors that he posted the cartoon because he thought it was “funny.”

The media reports do not include the drawing – presumably that could put journalists afoul of the law. So we do not know for sure what the youth is accused of sharing.

An actual Charlie Hebdo from July 2013 caused outrage for mocking Egyptian protestors killed after the military coup. The text says “The Quran is shit. It doesn’t stop bullets.”

An actual Charlie Hebdo from July 2013 caused outrage for mocking Egyptian protestors killed after the military coup. The text says “The Quran is shit. It doesn’t stop bullets.”

But the cartoon at the top of this page fits the description precisely. It was widely shared on social media, and published on 7 January on the website of the controversial French comedian Dieudonné. It is a mock Charlie Hebdo cover by the cartoonist Dedko.

The text says “Charlie Hebdo is shit. It does not stop bullets.” It appears quite heartless and cruel, but look at the copy of Charlie Hebdo that the person in the cartoon is holding.

It represents a real Charlie Hebdo cover that was published in July 2013, days after the military coup in Egypt. It caused outrage at the time because of its cruelty and insensitivity.

It shows an Egyptian protestor being shot through a copy of the Quran he is holding. The text says, “The Quran is shit, it doesn’t stop bullets.”

Assuming that the mock Charlie Hebdo cover is the one shared by the youth on Facebook, this incident sums up the sheer hypocrisy of France’s current national mood.

Anything mocking and denigrating Islam and Muslims is venerated as courageous free speech, while anything mocking those who engage in such denigration – even using precisely the same techniques – can get you locked up.

Continue reading…

, , , , , , , ,

  • xploratorul

    THIS is funny 🙂

  • Pingback: Imaginary Islamophobic strawmen: Islamic extremism | askanislamicist()

  • cmyfe .

    Yeah yeah! it is a great “value” as long as it doesn’t hit “you” where it hurts. Do you even read the articles before commenting troll?

  • Mohamed Al Saadoon

    Ahhhh….I thought it was Mifune in Yojimbo. Hell, if you search “Toshiro Mifune” in google images, that pic of Nakadai shows up.

    It seems I wasn’t the only one to make the mistake!

  • George Carty

    Or “je suis charlatan” as Private Eye magazine put it…

  • Reynardine

    Cite or fight.

  • The greenmantle

    Other news from France .
    Normally I dont like to see a family have a row in public but I am happy to make an exception for the Le Pen family 😉
    Marine has fallen out with her father and cousin because they believe Martine has become too left wing and is hanging out with unsiutable types such as homosexuals and Bibi. So at a time everyone thought that the President would suffer at the poles and approval ratings he looks to be doing better than those most people would do better like the Le pen family firm of FN.

    Sir David

  • Lithium2006

    Orwell never made anything up, much of what he has written about has come true in a way over the decades. Hell, his work has pretty much been a guide to controlling the masses.

Powered by Loon Watchers